Comment

Apr 19, 2017altissima rated this title 0.5 out of 5 stars
The authors have plainly done their research, and their picture of late Roman civilization is quite good. And they are decent writers. The text flows well and the descriptions are clear and vivid. Unfortunately the main character, Nicole, is an obnoxious twit, "merely a vehicle for the authors to satirize contemporary attitudes" as the School LIbrary Journal says above. And unlike the Journal, I don't see that she improves in any way; certainly she doesn't deepen. Everything that happens to her in the past is presented with a smug righteousness on the authors' part: she deserved this, she'll only get a clue if hit over the head with it! And maybe the authors think she's a better person at the end, but for me, she ends as paper-thin as she began, still a caricature. For a very much more eloquent version of this comment, see Jo Walton's review on Tor.com, "I'd love this book if I didn't loathe the protagonist".